Inside Point72: "The transition from analyst to portfolio manager is really, really hard"
It's always a tough time to be an analyst in a hedge fund, but recent times have been particularly harsh. Claude is pretty special at analysis work and many hedge funds aren't having a good year. Beneath the poor top level performance at big multistrategy funds is a world of pain involving the closure of entire pods, including portfolio managers (PMs) and the analysts who were supporting them - even if the analysts weren't entirely to blame.
💥Follow us on WhatsApp for news alerts.💥
Point72 is doing better than many other funds. Although it was down 2.3% in October's fixed income turmoil, Bloomberg reported that Point72 generated 8.4% after fees in the year to September. This might be because of investment mix. But in equities, at least, it might also be because Point72 invests heavily in nurturing the analysts who inform its investment decisions.
“The transition from analyst to PM is really, really hard,” says Reid Murphy, head of business development for Europe at Point72. Going straight from analysis to portfolio management is a bit like flying a plane that you're simultaneously building, says Murphy. You may crash.
Helpfully, then, Point72 runs an analyst-to-portfolio manager training program called LaunchPoint. It nurtures investment staff until they can run their own strategies. 55% of the equities portfolio managers at the firm started in LaunchPoint, says Murphy. Many arrive from banks where they worked in equity research or on investment banking sector teams. Some come from private equity. Some come from left field areas like scientific research.
Getting onto the programme is a challenge in itself. Up to 20 interviews are possible. There are modelling tests and case studies. There are interviews with multiple PMs. "We’ve found that the people who give us the best reads on who will be successful are the people currently doing the job,” says Murphy.
LaunchPoint applicants who stand out show "qualitative skills, judgement and critical thinking," says Murphy. You need to go to car showrooms to investigate cars you're researching instead of just looking at a screen. You need an edge.
If you make it onto the LaunchPoint programme and through to becoming an an actual equities PM, you'll need to be an expert in the particular sector you're opining on. But you'll also need to be an "idea generator." You will need to "come up with trading ideas on both the long and short side." And you will need to show that your ideas can scale: "Can you put meaningful capital behind the ideas you’re generating?”
This is all harder than it seems. "You can know names and have ideas, but what if you put meaningful capital behind them? You need to generate ideas independently, not just via a modelling template,” Murphy tells us. “There’s no set pathway. It’s not like a bank, where you go from level to level."
You will also require the P word. Passion. As analysts across the industry have recently discovered to their detriment, working for a hedge fund is not easy. “This job is a grind," Murphy says. "It’s not like on TV where you’re masters of the universe. You’re in day in, day out, trying to find the minutiae of what a company said one month versus another."
Passion for a big bonus won't carry you through, though. "You need passion for the job that goes beyond the monetary rewards. If you’re coming for the money, the job will wear you down in the periods when you don’t make money," says Murphy.
It helps, too, if you stay in your seat. The hedge fund industry is full of people switching jobs for guarantees and paid non-competes. Rivals are always trying to poach Point72's portfolio managers, says Murphy, but 70% of the firm's equity PMs who came through LaunchPoint are still there after five years. “Jumping around from seat to seat is destructive," he says. "What matters is longevity.”
Remember that in the year to come, whichever fund you work for.
Follow me on X. Follow me on LinkedIn.
Have a confidential story, tip, or comment you’d like to share? Contact: +44 7537 182250 (SMS, Whatsapp or voicemail). Telegram: @SarahButcher. Signal: sarahbutcher.22 Click here to fill in our anonymous form, or email editortips@efinancialcareers.com.
Bear with us if you leave a comment at the bottom of this article: comments are moderated intermittently by human beings. Sometimes these humans might be asleep, or away from their desks, so it may take a while for your comment to appear. You must take sole responsibility for comments you post on this site. We will take reasonable steps to weed out anything that we consider to be offensive or inappropriate